love u2, and it's electric - by paul angles
Wednesday, April 15, 2009 at 06:55AM
On April 8, 1987, at the Summit in Houston, TX, the world’s worst U2 cover band took the stage. They looked exactly like Bono, The Edge, Larry and Adam. They sang songs from The Joshua Tree and sounded exactly like album. They also played a few greatest hits from the previous albums. It was, of course, the actual U2, slavishly playing their own songs exactly as they’d been recorded.
The point here is not to knock one of the greatest bands ever for giving lame concert the one time I had tickets to see them. As neither a poet, a singer or a musician, I haven’t earned the right. Besides, even their unreleased B-sides album is so good that it put all but the very best of 80s to shame.
No, the point is that it’s hard to be as great as U2, even when you are U2.
Jeff Leisawitz’s Electron Love Theory is most definitely not U2 and does not try to be. And that’s a good thing because his electronic “tribute” album In The Shadows of U2 is not an album of covers or even a tribute in the traditional sense, but a deconstructing and reconstructing songs you’ve heard a million times into something incredibly brave and really, really good.
U2 songs break down into three components: Bono’s singing, The Edge’s guitar, and the poetic lyrics.
Bono, the quintessential front man, may be the face of U2 but The Edge is actually the voice. Leisawitz’s reconstruction, he substitutes Bono with different female vocalists on each of the 14 tracks. With very few exceptions, I honestly didn’t miss him. And because each singer brought a different style and vocal quality to each song, each jumped in unexpected ways. None of them can match Bono’s power, but they make up for it with emotion and nuance.
For example, Trish Shallest’s Bullet The Blue Sky was unnerving and effective in ways the original denunciation of the military-industrial complex never could. Allison Bazarko flipped I Will Follow inside out from The Boy Who Tries Hard To Be A Man to the Mother Who Takes Him By His Hand. The effect is positively Oedipal.
Wisely, I think, Leisawitz doesn’t try to match The Edge’s virtuosity note for note. Instead he mixes guitar and bass, drums and electronica loops into a more rhythmic support of the vocals, allowing his singers to step up and shine instead of competing with them. His tracks are richly patterned and layered, powerful when needed, but subtle and restrained much of the time.
More importantly, though, is that he allows the lyrics to shine in ways that U2, between competitiveness of Bono’s singing and The Edge’s playing, seem to forget. For the first time in years, I felt the loss in I Still Haven’t Found What I’m Looking For and the hope on New Year’s Day. They were always there, of course, just buried under all that U2.
Of course, as always happens when you push the limits, occasionally In The Shadows of U2 comes up short. Sunday, Bloody Sunday without the ironic, faux militarism of the original just doesn’t have the same angry, anti-violence message. It’s just too soft and feminine.
In all, however, there’s a reason why In The Shadows of U2 is doing so well in the streets of Germany and Austria and is so highly regarded on iTunes. It takes incredible courage to take on rock legends and unbelievable talent to pull it off. Jeff Leisawitz has worked for years on this project and his persistence has paid off.
On a related note, I listened to U2’s new album. Once. Enough said.
Electron Love Theory website
In The Shadows of U2 on iTunes

